US Particular Consultant for Afghanistan Reconciliation Zalmay Khalilzad (left) and Taliban co-founder Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar shake arms after signing a peace settlement throughout a ceremony within the Qatari capital Doha on February 29, 2020. PHOTO: AFP
It’s fascinating to observe the protection and commentary on the US-Taliban peace deal of February 29, 2020. It’s unhappy to see most Afghan analysts following the Western speaking factors, alleging that the Taliban are feigning peace; that they can’t be trusted; and that they might brutalise the Afghan liberal brigade like they did earlier than. Let’s get all the way down to fundamentals, as fundamentals are forgotten in a debate with out focus.
Who introduced a semblance of peace and stability to Afghanistan, after the period of warlords within the 1990s, guaranteeing a very powerful proper — the best to dwell? Who have been faraway from energy by the invaders and for what crime? Who fought the struggle of liberation? Who nurtured the struggle of freedom with their blood and sweat? Who didn’t succumb to Western inducements and pressures and remained steadfast to their fatherland fairly than leaving for greener pastures, after which returning to rule their nation on the shoulders of invaders? Who wrote the wonderful chapters of latest Muslim navy historical past by defeating two superpowers — an aberration from the norm? Who can stand like a bulwark towards the better menace of ISIS? And who could make Afghanistan peaceable, govern it and defend its nationhood? The reply to all of the above questions is certainly the Taliban.
One may suppose otherwise however info are info and actuality can’t be blinked away; so, somewhat realism in evaluation would do properly to the war-weary Afghans, whose love causes the analyst group many sleepless nights. Have we forgotten that the CIA paramilitaries using with Shumali warlords, have been hand-in-glove to drive the Taliban from energy by way of incessant machinations and B-52 carpet-bombing, with Sheberghan taking place proper underneath their nostril? The crime of the Taliban was sheltering Osama bin Laden — the presumed and but to be confirmed mastermind of 9/11. The US determined to invade Afghanistan within the footsteps of imperial Britain and Soviet Union, solely to finish up within the graveyard of empires. And true to their character, the Shumali warlords and opportunists of all shades, rallied across the invaders underneath the coat and tie management of imported expat group — with dual-nationality to “modernise Afghanistan making it heaven on earth”. And for 19 lengthy years, by way of shifting politico-strategic objectives, corruption on the mega scale, vacillation strengthened by a scarcity of sociological understanding of a tribal society, with a deeply entrenched love of Islam, this enterprise failed and failed spectacularly. PTSD, suicides and different illnesses have been pay-offs for killing with abandon and bombing marriage events. The agony continues in its many kinds.
Is Afghanistan actually democratic at the moment? Is it at peace after 49 international locations tried to take action by way of the may of NATO and US navy machines? Are Afghan girls any freer? Is the nation an oasis of stability in an in any other case chaotic neighbourhood? If the reply to those questions is not any — which it’s — then why ought to the Taliban not be given the ability that was snatched from them by way of the barrel of the gun? And why would they discuss to the sell-out Mir Jaffars and Mir Sadiqs amongst them, who amassed fortunes over the lifeless our bodies of their compatriots together with girls and youngsters. Let’s get our bearings proper and browse the not-too-distant Afghan historical past. Donald Trump — the deal-maker — has understood this and if Ashraf Ghani and his cabal don’t get it, they might achieve this at their very own peril. Najeebullah was on the gallows in pock-marked Kabul. It’s about time the Taliban get what they deserve they usually be taken on their phrase. The New York Instances op-ed by Sirajuddin Haqqani is their acknowledged street map.
The Afghan Taliban fought courageously, persistently and with steadfast conviction to eject the US and the allied forces from their homeland, combating a wonderful struggle of liberation by any definition. The historical past of this struggle is written by their blood and sweat. Their proper to struggle for liberation was an inalienable proper granted to them by all civilised conventions. Anticipating them to give up the fruits of their hard-won freedom on a platter to these Afghans who labored towards them in collusion with the invading forces is unjust, silly and unrealistic.
What couldn’t be performed by way of the navy may of the entire industrialised world ought to now be tried by way of a simply and sensible power-sharing, which is the primary rivalry begging decision by way of the intra-Afghan dialogue. With the Individuals reducing free in an election yr, Abdullah Abdullah asserting his parallel authorities, Afghan donor international locations taking successful because of the coronavirus, the Afghan safety forces in two, fairly three minds; the current Afghan authorities can by no means ever present peace and stability that each Afghan yearns for, not to mention stand as much as the Taliban juggernaut.
Whenever you renege on dedication by refusing to launch prisoners in a deal signed by your banker, you don’t assist your nation and your individuals — you, in reality, use prisoners as a human protect in a pathetic and fearful present of leverage. If the sentiment of the Taliban rank and file and post-Soviet Afghan historical past are any information, the regime should make peace at no matter value whereas the US remains to be there. With US troops gone, the regime would lose that leverage. Najeebullah was saved on the ventilator by erstwhile USSR for 2 years; the Ghani-Abdullah dichotomy would fall like a home of playing cards towards the twin Taliban-ISIS menace, as assessed not too long ago by the US authorities. In occasions of nervous disease-fighting and profound uncertainty, the Afghan regime shouldn’t count on any assist — monetary or navy. A compromise with the Taliban, the ascendant drive is writing on the wall, as the choice could quickly be a give up.
The Afghan Structure, girls rights, madar-pidar azadi, and so forth are all ethos of a minuscule city elite in a rustic the place the at the start precedence must be peace and security of life throughout the board. As argued on this house beforehand, the Taliban would want steady monetary assist to run the federal government, therefore the leverage with the world. However anticipating them to comply with a lopsided power-sharing association — that the Afghan authorities goals at — can be as futile as combating them for twenty years.
The US, China, Russia and Pakistan perceive that the Taliban can present governance, stability and subdue ISIS. The Afghan authorities wants to grasp this too. In these occasions of coronavirus pandemic, all sides must take a actuality examine with peace because the centerpiece.
Revealed in The Categorical Tribune, March 26th, 2020.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, observe @ETOpEd on Twitter to obtain all updates on all our every day items.
